ASTM D1729 Standard Practice for Visual Appraisal of Colors and Color Differences of Diffusely Illuminated Opaque Materials

    What is ASTM D1729? 

    ASTM D1729 describes a standard practice for visually appraising colors and color differences in opaque materials under diffuse illumination. This practice establishes the equipment and viewing conditions necessary to make these specifications critical in determining color matching, including judgments by at least normally sighted color vision observers, preferably with superior color vision as defined by the FM-100 Hue Test in Guide E1499. ASTM D1729 (Standard Practice for Visual Appraisal of Colors and Color Differences of Diffusely-Illuminated Opaque Materials) specifies that the principal reference illuminants are simulated average daylight, D65, and D50, which is recommended for color photography and color printing. Colors that appear the same under one light source are generally checked under another, very different, source to look for any discrepancies, a process called metamerism. Engineers use this practice to make color evaluations of opaque materials uniform in industries like paint, textiles, and plastics. 

    Read more

    Get Certified ASTM D1729 for Reliable Color Matching Quality 

    Certified ASTM D1729 evaluation is essential for manufacturers because instrument-only color matches do not necessarily predict how a color will look to a human observer under real-world viewing conditions. Standardizing visual examination has greatly contributed to product uniformity in many industries because it is done under standard illumination, viewing geometry, and qualified personnel. Certified evaluation confirms that a batch of colored material is appraised under conditions that produce reliable, repeatable color matching decisions. 

    What is the Scope of ASTM D1729? 

    ASTM D1729 specifies the equipment and procedures for the visual appraisal of colors and color differences of opaque materials that are diffusely illuminated, and these specifications are of critical importance in color matching. This practice uses the judgments of observers having at least normal color vision, and preferably better color vision, measured by the FM-100 Hue Test described in Guide E1499. The illumination required for critical visual appraisal of color and color difference of materials such as metallic and pearlescent paints is almost a geometric simulation of direct sunlight, as it provides the necessary illumination for the observation of sparkle and goniochromatism, which are outside the scope of this practice. The values in SI units are considered standard, and the values in parentheses are provided for information only.

    Read more

    The scope of ASTM D1729 includes: 

    • Material type: Opaque materials judged with diffused light for color and color difference. 
    • Purpose: To establish a uniform visual color appraisal system for color matching applications. 
    • Properties measured: Color and color difference between specimens. 
    • Method: Qualified observers make a visual comparison of the samples under the defined diffuse illumination and viewing conditions.  
    • Result: Judgment of color match, mismatch, or the perceived color difference. 
    • Test Limitations: Not applicable to metallic or pearlescent paints that require near-geometric simulation to observe sparkle and goniochromatism. 
    • Use conditions: Simulated average daylight (D65) is recommended, and D50 is recommended for color photography or color printing uses. 
    • Applications: Color-matching quality control in the paint, textile, plastic, and printed products industries. 

    What are the Uses of ASTM D1729?

    ASTM D1729 evaluation provides a uniformly accepted method for visually evaluating color and color difference for opaque materials, while a quality control team analyzes the results to ensure color match before products are produced. This standard-

    • Creates uniformity in the equipment and viewing conditions for visual color appraisal.
    • Assists in color selection of paint, fabrics, plastics, and other translucent materials.
    • Supports identification of metamerism to verify color matches under a second source of light.
    • Helps in the qualification of observers for color judgment in the FM-100 Hue Test.
    • Operates under three different illumination conditions: daylight (D65), photography, and printing (D50).
    • Helps manufacturers ensure uniformity in products by visual inspection. 

    What Materials Are Covered and Tested Under ASTM D1729? 

    ASTM D1729 applies to opaque materials tested for color and color difference under diffuse illumination, such as paints, textiles, plastics, and other colored products across many sectors. The materials excluded from the practice are metallic and pearlescent paints, which show sparkle and goniochromatism and for whose correct observation a near-geometric simulation of direct sunlight is necessary. Laboratories take samples and compare them to standard color reference samples under the conditions of illumination specified. 

    Why is ASTM D1729 Important? 

    ASTM D1729 evaluation provides manufacturers the opportunity to use uniform illumination, viewing conditions, and observation standards, helping to ensure that the color decision is reliable and repeatable among different production lots. Color measuring instruments are very much in use, but color matching is generally done visually, and the standardization of visual examination has resulted in greater uniformity in products produced in a number of industries. The colors may look identical under one type of light source but not another, so confirming a match under a second source, very different than the first, helps identify metamerism before it is a problem in the field. 

    ASTM D1729 Equipment and Sample Preparation Guide

    The ASTM D1729 evaluation test requires a viewing booth or enclosure that provides a diffuse light source, standardized light sources (D65 and D50), and a neutral background for comparison with the specimen. Samples are prepared and presented to the eye along with standard color reference samples. 

    Read more

    Sample and Specimen DetailsTechnicians use test specimens of opaque materials under diffuse illumination. Technicians ensure specimens have the same gloss and texture as the standard to maximize accuracy. 
    Specimen PreparationTechnicians prepare specimens and ensure they are clean and free from defects. Technicians use the preferred specimen size of approximately 90 x 165 mm (3 x 6 in.). Smaller sizes may reduce accuracy. 
    Specimen DimensionsTechnicians use specimens measuring approximately 90 x 165 mm (3 x 6 in.). 
    InstrumentationTechnicians use a standard light booth or viewing cabinet with D65 simulated daylight, a neutral gray background, and controlled viewing geometry. 

    Testing Procedures and Requirements for ASTM D1729  

    ASTM D1729 evaluation compares a test specimen to an ASTM color reference illuminated under diffuse light. Technicians view both examples simultaneously under a D65 illuminant and agree on the judgment under a second illuminant, such as D50 or incandescent. Other referenced ASTM documents include ASTM D523, D1535, D4086, D553, E284, and E308.

    Read more

    Specimen Preparation Technicians prepare specimens and ensure they are clean and free from defects. They verify that specimen gloss and texture match the standard to maximize appraisal accuracy. 
    Illumination Setup Technicians set the light booth to D65 simulated daylight or another specified illuminant. 
    Visual Comparison Observers compare test specimens against the standard under controlled illumination. They position specimens and standards side by side for direct comparison. 
    Color Difference Assessment Observers evaluate color difference in terms of hue, lightness, and saturation components. They note the order of prominence and may exchange materials and repeat the evaluation for critical assessment. 
    Result Reporting Laboratories report the visual judgment of color match or the direction and magnitude of color difference. 

    ASTM D1729 Testing Process and Data Collection

    The process starts with an analyst selecting representative specimens and a standard color reference for comparison. The technician then holds both specimens simultaneously in a diffuse D65 light source with a neutral background. Qualified observers make a color match during an evaluation and verify the match under a second light source to confirm metamerism. The analysts then record the observed color match, mismatch, or difference to control quality. 

     The image depicts a qualified observer comparing opaque material specimens under diffuse daylight illumination per ASTM D1729.
    ASTM D1729 Visual Color Appraisal Under Diffuse Illumination

    Common Challenges and Troubleshooting

    The proper evaluation of ASTM D1729 requires consistent diffuse illumination, a properly qualified observer, and a neutral viewing background that is free of distracting colors. The variation in ambient lighting, unqualified observers, and inconsistent presentation of specimens are frequent causes of inconsistent color judgments. These problems are minimized by using a calibrated viewing booth and verifying the observer’s color vision with the FM-100 Hue Test. Laboratories also obtain more consistent results if they test specimens under two different types of light sources, D65 and the other, to detect metameric mismatches. 

    ASTM D1729 Analysis Results and Interpretation

    This report provides a summary of the visual color appraisal carried out on the opaque material specimen under test. It documents the light conditions, observer qualifications, and judgment used in the evaluation. This interpretation is a comparison of actual color match/difference to applicable specification and/or purchase order limits.

    Read more

    • The laboratory records whether the specimen matched the standard color reference under D65 illumination.
    • The technician records the result of the secondary illumination test performed to identify metamerism.
    • The analyst records the observer’s color vision qualification (according to the FM-100 Hue Test).
    • The engineer considers the type of illumination, the viewing geometry, and background color when assessing the color judgment.
    • The manufacturer relies on the recorded color appraisal to accept and control colored product specifications. 

    Link to ASTM D1729 

    FAQ

    Why is there a need to test a color match under a second light source in ASTM D1729?
    Colors may match under one spectral power distribution but not under another; therefore, checking for a match under a second, quite distinct light source will help to identify metamerism before it causes any trouble in use.
    The International Commission on Illumination (CIE) recommends using simulated average daylight (D65) for applications such as color photography or color printing, and D50 for applications involving color printing.
    No, metallic and pearlescent paint materials should only be illuminated close to a geometric simulation of direct sunlight. If we want to see the sparkle and goniochromatism in paint, this is beyond the scope of this practice.
    Observers must possess a minimum of normal color vision, and preferably have superior color vision, as determined by the FM-100 Hue Test outlined in Guide E1499.

    Updated on October 2, 2026

    Gokula Srinivasan Selvam
    About Author
    Gokula Srinivasan Selvam is a Material Testing Associate at Matestlab Inc. and holds a postgraduate degree in Ceramic Engineering from IIT (BHU), Varanasi. His academic background and professional experience are centered on advanced ceramic materials, their processing, characterization, and performance evaluation.
    Know More
    Testimonials
    Real results
    Engineers trust us with what matters most
    Why Choose Matestlab?
    Matestlab is a unified testing services partner based in the USA. Matestlab offers raw material and product testing services through accredited, expert laboratories primarily based in the USA. Matestlab supports physical, thermal, chemical, electrical, mechanical, environmental, and characterization testing needs through its global network of 2200+ accredited testing laboratories. Matestlab's in-house materials science experts curate and design comprehensive testing programs matched to the sample material and specific testing need, with regulatory requirements and confidentiality in mind.

    If you are looking for a managed and trusted testing partner to achieve your research goals, feel free to schedule a meeting with us or send us a request at connect@matestlabs.com to learn more about our services. For a quick quote, call us at (302)244-7710. We are happy to serve you.
    Start Your Testing
    Project Today
    Define your requirements and get access to
    specialized laboratories ready to deliver results
    Partners with us
    Clients
    Vendors
    Process for testing
    • STEP 01

      You share your testing requirements

    • STEP 02

      You share your sample(s)

    • STEP 03

      We deliver your test reports

    Get your testing done

    Let us know your testing requirements and we will be right back with a solution.

      Let us root for each other. Collaborate to grow, expand, and accelerate our businesses.

      Partner with us